When it comes to choosing the perfect running shoe, two brands often stand out: On Cloud and Brooks.
Both offer high-quality footwear designed to enhance your running experience, but how do they compare?
We’ll explore the key features of On Cloud and Brooks shoes, helping you make an informed decision for your next pair of running shoes.
Contents
On Cloud vs Brooks Shoes
The main difference between On Cloud and Brooks shoes lies in their design philosophy. On Cloud focuses on lightweight, responsive footwear with innovative cushioning, while Brooks prioritizes traditional comfort, durability, and support for various running needs.
Now, let’s create a detailed comparison table for On Cloud vs Brooks Shoes:
| Feature | On Cloud | Brooks |
| Brand Origin | Swiss (founded 2010) | American (founded 1914) |
| Specialty | Performance running, lifestyle | Running-focused |
| Key Technology | CloudTec cushioning | DNA LOFT, GuideRails support |
| Cushioning | Lightweight, responsive | Soft, plush |
| Weight | Generally lighter | Typically heavier |
| Price Range | $130 – $200+ | $100 – $160+ |
| Fit | Tends to run narrow | Offers wider options |
| Durability | Moderate | Generally high |
| Stability | Neutral to mild stability | Offers neutral and high stability options |
| Popular Models | Cloudflow, Cloudstratus | Ghost, Adrenaline GTS |
| Eco-Friendly Options | Yes (e.g., Cyclon subscription) | Yes (e.g., Ghost 15 with recycled materials) |
| Style | Modern, sleek design | Traditional running shoe aesthetic |
| Target Audience | Performance runners, casual wearers | Primarily serious runners |
| Availability | Growing, but less widespread | Widely available |
In summary: Both brands have their strengths, with On Cloud excelling in lightweight performance and style, while Brooks shines in comfort, support, and durability. The choice between them often comes down to personal preferences in feel, fit, and running style.
Brand Overview
On Cloud: Swiss Engineering Meets Running Innovation
On Cloud, founded in 2010 in Switzerland, has quickly become a favorite among runners worldwide. Known for their unique CloudTec® technology, On shoes promise a soft landing with explosive take-off. The brand’s commitment to innovation and sleek design has earned them a dedicated following among both casual joggers and serious athletes.
Brooks: A Legacy of Running Excellence
Brooks has been in the running game since 1914, evolving into a brand solely focused on running shoes and apparel. With a rich history of technological advancements, Brooks is renowned for its dedication to creating shoes that cater to various running styles and foot types. Their commitment to “Run Happy” philosophy resonates with runners of all levels.
Durability
On Cloud Durability
On Cloud shoes are built to last, thanks to their high-quality materials and innovative design. The Cloudtec® outsole, made from zero-gravity foam, offers excellent durability without compromising on weight. Many users report their On Cloud shoes maintaining their shape and performance even after hundreds of miles.
Brooks Durability
Brooks is well-known for producing durable running shoes. Their use of high-abrasion rubber in high-wear areas of the outsole contributes to long-lasting performance. Brooks also incorporates technologies like DNA LOFT and BioMoGo DNA in their midsoles, which retain their cushioning properties over time.
Durability Verdict
While both brands offer durable options, Brooks might have a slight edge in overall longevity, especially for high-mileage runners. However, On Cloud shoes often maintain their aesthetic appeal longer, which could be a deciding factor for some users.
Breathability
On Cloud Breathability
On Cloud shoes feature engineered mesh uppers that provide excellent ventilation. The lightweight construction allows for ample airflow, keeping your feet cool and dry during runs. Some models even incorporate antimicrobial treatments to combat odor-causing bacteria.
Brooks Breathability
Brooks also excels in breathability, using various mesh technologies in their uppers. Their Fit Knit and Air Mesh materials offer superb ventilation while maintaining structure. Some Brooks models feature 3D Fit Print technology, which enhances breathability without sacrificing support.
Breathability Verdict
Both brands perform admirably in terms of breathability. Your choice may come down to personal preference and the specific model you’re considering, as breathability can vary slightly between different shoe lines.
Cushioning
On Cloud Cushioning
On Cloud’s signature CloudTec® technology provides a unique cushioning experience. The hollow “cloud” elements in the sole compress upon impact and then lock to create a firm platform for push-off. This system aims to offer both soft landings and responsive take-offs.
Brooks Cushioning
Brooks offers various cushioning technologies, including DNA LOFT, BioMoGo DNA, and DNA AMP. These systems adapt to your stride, weight, and speed, providing personalized cushioning. Brooks tends to offer a more traditional cushioned feel compared to On Cloud’s distinctive approach.
Cushioning Verdict
If you prefer a unique, responsive cushioning experience, On Cloud might be your go-to. For those who appreciate a more traditional, plush cushioning feel, Brooks could be the better choice. It’s worth trying both to see which cushioning style suits your running preferences.
Shoe Fit
On Cloud Fit
On Cloud shoes generally offer a snug, performance-oriented fit. They tend to have a narrower toe box and a secure midfoot wrap. This design aims to reduce in-shoe movement and enhance responsiveness. However, some runners with wider feet may find certain On models too constricting.
Brooks Fit
Brooks is known for accommodating a variety of foot shapes. They offer multiple width options in many of their popular models, from narrow to extra-wide. Brooks shoes often feature a roomier toe box, which can be beneficial for runners who need more space for toe splay.
Fit Verdict
If you have narrow to average-width feet and prefer a snug fit, On Cloud might be ideal. For those with wider feet or who prefer more toe room, Brooks offers more versatility in fit options.
Stability
On Cloud Stability
On Cloud shoes provide stability through their unique sole design. The individual cloud elements and the central channel in the outsole work together to guide the foot through its natural motion. Some models, like the Cloudflyer, offer enhanced stability features for overpronators.
Brooks Stability
Brooks offers a range of stability options, from mild support to maximum stability. Their GuideRails® Holistic Support System, found in models like the Adrenaline GTS, provides support by keeping excess movement in check. This approach aims to reduce stress on the knees and other joints.
Stability Verdict
For runners needing mild to moderate stability, both brands offer suitable options. However, if you require maximum stability or have significant overpronation issues, Brooks’ more extensive range of stability shoes might be more appropriate.
Comfort
On Cloud Comfort
On Cloud shoes are designed with comfort in mind, featuring soft, breathable uppers and their innovative cushioning system. Many users report a “walking on clouds” sensation. However, the unique sole design may take some getting used to for some runners.
Brooks Comfort
Brooks prioritizes comfort across their entire range. Their shoes often feature plush collar linings, well-padded tongues, and cushioned insoles. The variety of width options also contributes to finding a comfortable fit for most foot types.
Comfort Verdict
Both brands excel in comfort, but in different ways. On Cloud offers a distinctive, cloud-like feel, while Brooks provides a more traditional, enveloping comfort. Personal preference will play a significant role in determining which brand feels more comfortable to you.
Quality
On Cloud Quality
On Cloud maintains high quality standards, using premium materials and innovative manufacturing techniques. Their shoes often feature seamless construction and attention to detail in both performance and aesthetic aspects.
Brooks Quality
Brooks has a long-standing reputation for producing high-quality running shoes. They use durable materials and rigorously test their shoes to ensure they meet the demands of serious runners.
Quality Verdict
Both On Cloud and Brooks are committed to producing high-quality running shoes. You’re unlikely to be disappointed with the quality of either brand, though On Cloud might have a slight edge in terms of innovative construction techniques.
Style
On Cloud Style
On Cloud shoes are known for their sleek, modern aesthetic. Their distinctive sole design and clean upper patterns make them stand out. Many runners appreciate that On Cloud shoes can transition seamlessly from running to casual wear.
Brooks Style
Brooks tends to focus more on function over fashion, though they have made strides in recent years to create more visually appealing designs. Their shoes often feature bold color combinations and performance-oriented aesthetics.
Style Verdict
If style is a priority and you appreciate a modern, versatile look, On Cloud might have the edge. For those more focused on pure performance aesthetics, Brooks offers plenty of attractive options.
Size and Fit
On Cloud Sizing
On Cloud shoes generally run true to size, though some users find they need to go up a half size, especially in models with a narrower toe box. It’s worth noting that European sizes are often used, so be sure to check size conversion charts.
Brooks Sizing
Brooks shoes typically run true to size and offer a range of width options. Their size chart is straightforward, and the variety of fits available makes it easier to find the right size for your foot shape.
Sizing Verdict
Both brands generally offer reliable sizing, but Brooks’ wider range of width options might make it easier to find your perfect fit, especially if you have particularly narrow or wide feet.
Materials
On Cloud Materials
On Cloud uses high-quality, lightweight materials in their shoes. This includes engineered mesh uppers, zero-gravity foam, and rubber compounds for the outsoles. They also incorporate recycled materials in some models, appealing to environmentally conscious consumers.
Brooks Materials
Brooks employs a variety of technical materials in their shoes, including their proprietary DNA cushioning compounds, engineered mesh uppers, and high-abrasion rubber outsoles. They also offer some models with waterproof Gore-Tex uppers.
Materials Verdict
Both brands use high-quality materials suited for performance running. On Cloud might have a slight edge in terms of lightweight construction, while Brooks offers more options for weather-resistant materials.
Weight
On Cloud Weight
On Cloud shoes are generally known for their lightweight design. Most models fall in the range of 200-300 grams (7-10.5 oz) for a men’s size 9, with some racing models even lighter.
Brooks Weight
Brooks offers a range of weights across their product line. While they have some lightweight racing options, their everyday trainers tend to be slightly heavier than comparable On Cloud models, typically ranging from 250-320 grams (8.8-11.3 oz) for a men’s size 9.
Weight Verdict
If you prioritize lightweight shoes, On Cloud generally offers lighter options across their range. However, Brooks’ slightly heavier shoes often provide more cushioning and support, which some runners prefer.
Flexibility
On Cloud Flexibility
On Cloud shoes offer a unique kind of flexibility. The individual cloud elements allow for natural foot movement, while the rigid speedboard promotes energy return. This results in a shoe that’s flexible in some ways but also provides a responsive, propulsive feel.
Brooks Flexibility
Brooks designs their shoes with strategic flex grooves in the outsole to promote natural foot movement. The level of flexibility varies across their range, with some models offering more flexibility for a natural ride, while others prioritize stability.
Flexibility Verdict
Both brands offer flexible options, but the feel is quite different. On Cloud’s flexibility is coupled with a distinctive responsive feel, while Brooks offers a more traditional flexible ride. Try both to see which style you prefer.
Water Resistance
On Cloud Water Resistance
While not all On Cloud shoes are waterproof, they do offer some water-resistant models, such as the Cloudventure Waterproof. These shoes use a membrane to keep water out while maintaining breathability.
Brooks Water Resistance
Brooks offers several waterproof options, particularly in their trail running line. These shoes often feature Gore-Tex membranes, providing excellent water resistance without sacrificing breathability.
Water Resistance Verdict
If water resistance is a priority, both brands offer suitable options. However, Brooks might have a slight edge with their more extensive range of Gore-Tex equipped models.
Sole Design
On Cloud Sole Design
On Cloud’s sole design is their most distinctive feature. The CloudTec® elements provide cushioning and responsiveness, while the central channel helps with flexibility and grip. The unique design aims to provide a soft landing with a firm take-off.
Brooks Sole Design
Brooks uses more traditional sole designs, with varying levels of cushioning and support. Their soles often feature segmented crash pads for smooth transitions and strategic groove placements for flexibility and traction.
Sole Design Verdict
On Cloud’s sole design is more innovative and unique, which some runners love. Brooks offers a more traditional approach that many runners find familiar and reliable. Your preference will depend on whether you’re looking for a novel running experience or a tried-and-true design.
User Reviews and Ratings
| Brand | Model | User Review | Rating |
| On Cloud | Cloudflow | “Incredibly lightweight and responsive. Perfect for my daily runs!” | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Brooks | Ghost 14 | “Comfortable right out of the box. Great cushioning for long distances.” | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| On Cloud | Cloudstratus | “The double-layer of clouds provides amazing cushioning. My go-to for marathons.” | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Brooks | Adrenaline GTS 22 | “Excellent stability without feeling bulky. Solved my overpronation issues.” | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| On Cloud | Cloudswift | “Stylish enough for casual wear, performant enough for serious running.” | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Brooks | Glycerin 19 | “Like running on pillows! Supreme comfort for my sensitive feet.” | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| On Cloud | Cloudflyer | “Great support for my long runs. The wider base gives me confidence.” | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Brooks | Launch 9 | “Lightweight and snappy. My favorite shoe for speed workouts.” | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
Price Comparison
| Category | On Cloud Model | On Cloud Price | Brooks Model | Brooks Price |
| Neutral Running | Cloudflow | $140 | Ghost 14 | $130 |
| Max Cushioning | Cloudstratus | $170 | Glycerin 19 | $150 |
| Stability | Cloudflyer | $160 | Adrenaline GTS 22 | $130 |
| Lightweight/Speed | Cloudflow | $140 | Launch 9 | $100 |
| Trail Running | Cloudventure | $150 | Cascadia 16 | $130 |
| Entry-level | Cloudswift | $150 | Revel 5 | $100 |
Pros and Cons
Pros: On Cloud Shoes
- Lightweight design
- Innovative CloudTec cushioning for responsive feel
- Stylish, modern aesthetics
- Good for speed work and short to medium distances
- Versatile for both running and casual wear
Cons: On Cloud Shoes
- Less cushioning for long-distance runs
- May wear out faster than some competitors
- Limited options for stability shoes
- Higher price point for some models
- May not provide enough support for those with specific foot issues
Pros: Brooks Shoes
- Excellent cushioning for long-distance comfort
- Wide range of stability options
- Durable construction for longevity
- Consistent fit across different models
- Good options for various foot types and sizes
Cons: Brooks Shoes
- Generally heavier than On Cloud shoes
- Less stylish for casual wear
- Can feel bulky for speed work
- Some may find the cushioning too soft
- Traditional designs may not appeal to those seeking modern aesthetics
Both brands have their strengths, and the choice ultimately depends on individual preferences, running style, and specific needs.
In conclusion: Both On Cloud and Brooks offer excellent running shoes, each with their own strengths. On Cloud stands out for its innovative designs, lightweight construction, and stylish aesthetics. They’re an excellent choice for runners who want a unique, responsive ride and shoes that can transition easily from running to casual wear.
Brooks, with its long history in running shoe manufacturing, offers a more traditional approach with a wide range of options to suit different running styles and foot types. They excel in providing shoes for runners who need specific types of support or who prefer a more conventional cushioning feel.
Are On Cloud shoes good for long-distance running?
Yes, many On Cloud models are suitable for long-distance running. The Cloudstratus, for example, is designed specifically for maximum cushioning over long distances.
Do Brooks shoes come in wide sizes?
Yes, many Brooks models are available in multiple widths, including wide and extra-wide options.
How long do On Cloud shoes typically last?
On Cloud shoes generally last between 300-500 miles, depending on the model and your running style.
Are Brooks shoes good for overpronators?
Yes, Brooks offers several models designed for overpronators, such as the Adrenaline GTS and the Beast.
Can On Cloud shoes be used for casual wear?
Absolutely! Many On Cloud shoes are designed to transition seamlessly from running to casual wear.